mirror of
https://github.com/cozystack/cozystack.git
synced 2026-11-22 04:33:36 +09:00
Two live-reproduced blockers in the in-place ZK->KRaft migration are
fixed, plus the concurrency guard behind them.
1. Data loss (node IDs). The migration created the broker and controller
KafkaNodePools together without pinning node IDs. On Strimzi 0.45 the
controller pool deterministically took the existing broker IDs
[0..N-1], so the brokers were recreated empty at [N..] and their data
PVCs were orphaned (reproduced 2/2 on dev9: 20000 messages -> 0,
partitions leaderless, migration wedged in KRaftMigration). Naming the
broker pool "kafka" is necessary but NOT sufficient: Strimzi adopts by
node id, not pool name. The controller pool now pins
strimzi.io/next-node-ids above the broker range, so the broker pool
keeps [0..N-1] and adopts the existing <cluster>-kafka-N brokers and
their data in place.
2. Release stuck "failed" (Helm lifecycle). The pre-upgrade hook creates
the pools, and the chart also declared them as regular manifests, so
Helm's main apply tried to reconcile a resource that exists in the
cluster but was absent from the previous (ZooKeeper) release revision
and aborted with "original object KafkaNodePool ... not found",
leaving the HelmRelease failed even though the cluster migrated fine
(reproduced 3/3 under server-side apply, the production
helm-controller path). This is unavoidable while the pools are Helm
main-manifest resources across the ZK->KRaft boundary, so the pools
are now managed entirely by the migration Job (a pre-install,
pre-upgrade hook) on every install and upgrade, and removed from the
regular manifests. The Job ensures both pools (creating or updating
them idempotently), then drives the migration state machine.
templates/kafkanodepools.yaml and the deployed-version gate ConfigMap
(templates/version.yaml) are removed; the broker pool name is resolved
per path by kafka.brokerPoolName ("b-<hash>" fresh, "kafka"
migrating), and the render-time name-length guard moves to the Kafka
CR template.
3. Concurrency (one migration per namespace). The collision guard read
the "kafka" pool owner and then applied, a non-atomic read-then-write
two concurrent per-namespace migrations could both pass. When the pool
is absent the hook now uses "kubectl create" as the atomic arbiter:
exactly one concurrent creator wins, the loser re-reads the owner and
aborts.
Verified live on dev9 under server-side apply: a fresh install comes up
KRaft with pools at [0,1,2]/[3,4,5] and the release is "deployed"; an
in-place migration of a 20000-message ZooKeeper cluster ends "deployed",
adopts the broker PVCs in place (same UIDs), and the KRaft data is
byte-for-byte identical to the pre-migration ZooKeeper data (matching
sha256 over every partition:offset:key:value). helm-unittest 86/86 and
hack/kafka-migration-hook.bats 12/12 (the real hook script against a stub
kubectl) cover the resolution branches, the fail-closed reads, the atomic
collision guard and the finalize guard.
Signed-off-by: Alexey Artamonov <aleksei.artamonov@aenix.io>
How to test packages local
cd packages/core/installer
make image-cozystack REGISTRY=YOUR_CUSTOM_REGISTRY
make apply
kubectl delete po -l app=source-controller -n cozy-fluxcd