Files
cozystack/internal/operator
Myasnikov Daniil 16b8ea4f0e docs(operator): correct the VPA rationale on the request scan
The comment argued that the danger this scan guards against is a VPA
webhook writing a request above the defaulted limit, which is then
rejected at admission. Admission ordering rules that out. LimitRanger is
position 6 of AllOrderedPlugins and MutatingAdmissionWebhook is 35, so
the LimitRange has already defaulted the container's memory limit before
VPA is called, and VPA rescales that limit in proportion to the request
it writes (GetProportionalLimit, under the default controlledValues:
RequestsAndLimits). Request and limit stay consistent and the pod is
admitted.

Rewrite it around what can actually happen: a request already in the spec
when it reaches admission with no limit beside it. In this tree that means
an operator lowering --system-namespace-memory-limit below a statically
declared request -- the largest is 2Gi, in
packages/system/rabbitmq-operator, so the 4Gi default clears them all
today. Two narrower shapes are real too: a pod that predates the
LimitRange, whose own controller may build it from a custom resource no
workload template in this scan can show; and a VPA set to
controlledValues: RequestsOnly, where nothing rescales the defaulted limit
and the rejection returns. The second doubles as the residual gap, since
a first pod rejected outright appears in neither a template nor a pod
list.

The scan itself is unchanged; only the justification was wrong.

Also record why withholding the LimitRange had to go rather than merely
being suboptimal: in a namespace with no LimitRange nothing defaults a
memory limit, so the next VPA-sized pod arrives with a large request and
no limit, the scan finds it again, and the namespace is withheld again.
The old behaviour could never get its foot in the door in cozy-monitoring.

Assisted-By: LLM
Signed-off-by: Myasnikov Daniil <myasnikovdaniil2001@gmail.com>
2026-10-07 05:36:45 +03:00
..